The Hyde Park Herald reports that the University of Chicago, which previously withheld diplomas from eleven students for participating in our encampment, has given them back. This means that although the students were warned that being in the encampment was illegal, they, along with all the encampers, suffered no penalty for breaking University rules. The encampment was the fifth violation of University regulations by protestors that went unpunished.
This seems to be the general trend in most universities. Now that the tumultuous year has ended, universities are experiencing a wave of forgiveness—a wave that will come back to haunt them this fall. As far as I can see, no students were disciplined by the city of Chicago or by the University despite multiple and clear violations of both the law and University regulations. (This includes the Ciry of Chicago dropping trespassing charges against 24 students and two faculty who were arrested for violating University regulations for sit-ins in University buildings.}
In April I recounted the sad story of how remiss Chicago has been in punishing pro-Palestinian protestors who violated University regulations. As far as I know, the only puniahment levied the entire year, as described above, is a simple warning to the Students for Justice in Palestine that they had better desist from illegally disrupting and deplatforming opponents:
Official Warning – An official warning indicates the organization has violated University policies or regulations and will be placed on file. If the organization engages in any additional misconduct, the appropriate disciplinary body will be informed of this official warning, the related circumstances, and must consider the warning in determining further sanctions.
No that’s really going to deter illegal protests, isn’t it? As noted below, the protestors are proclaiming they’ll return this fall resuming their disruptions. Why wouldn’t they, when they know there’s no penalty for doing so?
Click below to read the Hyde Park Herald’s account of the restoration of diplomas:
An excerpt:
The last of the disciplinary cases against 10 University of Chicago students for their involvement in the pro-Palestine campus encampment was dismissed this week, student activists announced Monday.
Among those facing disciplinary cases were four graduating seniors and a graduate student, whose diplomas were withheld pending U. of C. investigations into potentially “disruptive conduct” at the encampment, which was erected on the Main Quadrangle in early May to protest the institution’s investments in weapons manufacturers arming Israel in its war on Gaza. Most of these cases – including those for another six undergraduate students – were dismissed last month, and the final one, the case of the graduate student, was dismissed and the degree conferred on August 12.
Youseff Hasweh, one of the four graduating seniors, said Monday that this final dismissal after months of pressure from students, alumni and faculty “tells UChicago that we’re never going to back down.”
“Students are even more fired up to join the movement and to let UChicago know that this wasn’t okay, that everything they’ve done this past year,” he said.
In addition to tearing down the encampment, U. of C. police officers arrested more than two dozen students and two faculty members during a November sit-in demanding divestment in the Israel-Hamas war and that the U. of C. cut ties with Israel altogether. U. of C. officers also arrested one person during a commencement walkout this June.
As I said, the City dropped all charges against the two dozen students and two faculty members. I don’t know why this happened, but surely some punishment should be meted out by the University (as did Vanderbilt–see link above) for illegal sit ins, even if it’s only a note on the student’s transcript.
University regulations that aren’t enforced are regulations that are toothless and can be violated with impunity. I predict that the whole brouhaha will begin again this fall, as there’s simply no way the conflict between Israel and Hamas will be resolved by then. I’ll add this: those calling for a cease-fire in Gaza, including candidate Kamala Harris, realize that, by leaving Hamas in power, such a move will ensure that Israel will be forever subject to Palestinian terrorism—until the Jewish state is destroyed by an Iranian nuke.
As for my University, the paper says this:
Administrators for the U. of C. could not be reached for comment regarding the alleged photos as of press time.
That, of course, means they have no comment.
Get ready for fall—it will be a bumpy ride.
Most rational people, I believe, are opposed to academic boycotts: those political movements that try to prohibit the exchange of scholars or academic information with countries deemed unacceptable on ideological grounds. These boycotts not only stem the free flow of information among countries that is the lifeblood of academia—especially of science—but also punish those who can contribute to this knowledge even though those people rarely have any influence with their government. Indeed, as in the case of Israel (surely the reason for the dropping of the boycott prohibition), many scholars are opposed to the government’s policies.
Inside Higher Ed (click below to read) reports on the ending of boycotts by the influential organization the American Association of University Professors, an organization that should know better. Click to read:
The report:
The American Association of University Professors (AAUP) has dropped its nearly 20-year-old categorical opposition to academic boycotts, in which scholars and scholarly groups refuse to work or associate with targeted universities. The reversal, just like the earlier statement, comes amid war between Israelis and Palestinians.
In 2005, near the end of the second intifada, a Palestinian uprising, the AAUP denounced such boycotts; the following year, it said they “strike directly at the free exchange of ideas.” That statement has now been replaced by one saying boycotts “can be considered legitimate tactical responses to conditions that are fundamentally incompatible with the mission of higher education.” The new statement doesn’t mention Israel, Palestine or other current events—but the timing isn’t coincidental.
The new position says that “when faculty members choose to support academic boycotts, they can legitimately seek to protect and advance the academic freedom and fundamental rights of colleagues and students who are living and working under circumstances that violate that freedom and one or more of those rights.”
Note that the AAUP never prevented individual professors from deciding not to cooperate with faculty from other countries. Rather, they used to aver that systematic academic boycotts were not approved by the organization. Now that’s all changed: systematic boycotts are okay. But o its credit, the University of Chicago, under the late President Bob Zimmer, opposed academic boycotts in a 2013 statement, and our opposition remains intact:
“The University of Chicago has from its founding held as its highest value the free and open pursuit of inquiry. Faculty and students must be free to pursue their research and education around the world and to form collaborations both inside and outside of the academy, encouraging engagement with the widest spectrum of views. For this reason, we oppose boycotts of academic institutions or scholars in any region of the world, and oppose recent actions by academic societies to boycott Israeli institutions.”
That’s the way a gutsy university handles such matters. Sadly, the AAUP punted (read its statement at the link). The AAUP’s statement was also heartily approved by a group participating in the BDS (Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions) movement, an antisemitic initiative whose goal is to eliminate Israel as a Jewish state. Click to read:
An excerpt:
The Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (PACBI) commends the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) for dropping its biased, unethical policy opposing academic boycotts, which was primarily aimed at shielding Israeli universities from accountability for their egregious human rights violations.
PACBI salutes all those who worked tirelessly to push the AAUP to change its position, as well as the conscientious academics, students, and progressive academic associations that have for years advocated for ending US academic institutional complicity with Israel’s 76-year-old regime of settler-colonialism and apartheid and, in the process, challenging AAUP’s hypocrisy. Without their persistent protests and intellectual challenges, without the student-led encampments reenergizing campus campaigns for academic boycott and divestment in response to Israel’s Gaza genocide, the AAUP would not have reversed its ethically and logically untenable policy.
. . . Scrapping its unethical policy, which was, arguably by design, used to suppress academic freedom of many calling for BDS against Israel, the new AAUP position recognizes the obvious. It finally accepts that academic boycotts targeting institutions deeply implicated in grave human rights violations can be legitimate “to protect and advance the academic freedom and fundamental rights of colleagues and students who are living and working under circumstances that violate that freedom and one or more of those rights.”
The PCBI’s only beef is that the AAUP didn’t go far enough and denounce Israel specifically:
. . . AAUP’s failure to now endorse the Palestinian call to boycott complicit Israeli universities, which it finally recognizes as legitimate, even as Israel’s violence culminates in the world’s first livestreamed genocide, which has included scholasticide, domicide and engineered famine, is a profound ethical failure to make amends for the harm the AAUP’s racist policy has done to Palestinians and to our struggle for emancipation from colonial subjugation.
It’s clear from all this, as Inside Higher Ed notes, that the AAUP’s change of policy was to legitimize academic boycotts of Israel. The coincidence of timing is too strong to imply otherwise.
We have often stated here on SBM that vaccine programs are the most effective, and most cost-effective, public health measures in human history. They save lives, prevent disease, and save money. These benefits are all well researched and copiously documented. A recent CDC study adds to the literature on the benefits of vaccines and vaccine programs, focusing on the effects of the […]
The post Vaccines for Children Program Works first appeared on Science-Based Medicine.Meanwhile, in Dobrzyn, Hili is suspicious:
Hili: This leaf looks like a small animal. A: But it is a withered leaf.Hili: Ten liśc wygląda jak małe zwierzątko.
Primordial black holes formed during the earliest stages of the evolution of the universe. Their immense gravity may be playing havoc in stellar systems. They can transfer energy into wide binary systems disrupting their orbits. Like celestial bullies their disruption might lead to extreme outcomes though like the ejection of a star, only to be replaced by the black hole itself! A new paper studies the interactions of systems like these and looks at ways we might be able to detect them.
It’s been theorised that during the earliest moments after the Big Bang, black holes may have formed. They are not the result of supermassive stars having collapsed but instead have formed out of fluctuations in the density of matter. Regions with great density would simply collapse under their own gravitational influence forming what have been dubbed primordial black holes (PBHs). They are thought to vary in size from subatomic to some that are more massive than the Sun.
Whether primordial black holes really do account for dark matter in the universe is still up for debate. Among the astronomical community it is generally accepted that they cannot account for all dark matter but probably account for up to 10% of dark matter in the planetary mass range (10-7 to 10-3 solar masses.) Whether this is PBHs account for any of the dark matter in the universe requires further analysis.
Researchers are making progress mapping dark matter, but they don’t know what it is. This is a 3D density map of dark matter in the local universe, with the Milky Way marked by an X. Dots are galaxies, and the arrows indicate the directions of motion derived from the reconstructed gravitational potential of dark matter. Image Credit: Hong et al., doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/abf040.If large scale is taken into account then PBHs are indistinguishable from a background of particle dark matter. At small scales the distribution of PBHs is not uniform across the universe relative to the background of particle dark matter and so we are forced to look for a unique and new theory. Observing PBHs to understand how close the model is to reality is difficult but it is possible to study their interactions with star systems.
In a paper published by Badal Bhalla from the University of Oklahoma and a team of astronomers they explore the way PBHs can lose energy when interacting with stellar binary systems. These interactions can result in any one of 5 possible outcomes;
1: Hardening – the two bound objects lose energy to the third free object causing their separation to decrease;
2: Softening – the free body transfers energy to the bound system causing their separation to increase but remain bound;
3: Disruption – the free body transfers enough energy to the bound system that the components become unbound and all objects continue unbound;
4: Capture – the bound objects capture the free object;
5: Exchange – the free object transfers enough energy to unbind one of the bound objects and in doing so loses sufficient energy to become bound to the remaining one.
Previous studies have explored softening and disruption in PBH and binary interactions as has the capture model. The team propose that hardening is also unlikely and so explore the possibility of the exchange model. They find that the exchange model should lead to a population of PBH binaries in the Milky Way and indeed some observations hint that they may exist. The team also suggest it may be possible to detect PBHs in binary systems with a sub-solar mass PBH by the properties of the system. Observations are now needed to validate the model. The discovery of black holes in a binary system may be detectable and go some way to support the findings.
Source : Dancing with invisible partners: Three-body exchanges with primordial black holes
The post Primordial Black Holes Could Kick Out Stars and Replace Them. appeared first on Universe Today.
NASA’s Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE), launched in 2009, spent the next fourteen and half years studying the Universe in infrared wavelengths. During that time, it discovered thousands of minor planets, star clusters, and the first Brown Dwarf and Earth-Trojan asteroid. By 2013, the mission was reactivated by NASA as the Near-Earth Object Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (NEOWISE), which was tasked with searching for Potentially Hazardous Asteroids (PHAs). For ten years, the NEOWISE mission faithfully cataloged comets and asteroids that could pose a threat to Earth someday.
Unfortunately, NASA announced on July 1st that it would be decommissioning this planetary defense mission, which is expected to burn up in our atmosphere later this year. On Thursday, August 8th, the mission was decommissioned after the final command was sent from NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Southern California and related to the spacecraft by the Tracking and Data Relay Satellite (TDRS) system. However, the scientific data NEOWISE collected during its ten years of operation will continue to inspire new discoveries!
The decision to end the mission was made because of an uptick in solar activity that’s been heating Earth’s upper atmosphere, causing it to expand and create drag on the spacecraft. This will cause NEOWISE to drop too low in its orbit to provide accurate scientific data, and NEOWISE does not have a propulsion system to maintain its orbit. Past and present mission members attended the decommissioning ceremony, which took place at the Earth Orbiting Missions Operation Center (EOMOC) at NASA JPL and the agency’s headquarters in Washington, D.C.
Animation of the many Near-Earth Objects (NEOs) that share Earth’s orbit. Credit: NASA.The remaining scientific data was downlinked shortly after science operations officially ended on July 31st. Said Nicola Fox, associate administrator of NASA’s Science Mission Directorate at NASA HQ, in a recent NASA press release:
“The NEOWISE mission has been an extraordinary success story as it helped us better understand our place in the universe by tracking asteroids and comets that could be hazardous for us on Earth. While we are sad to see this brave mission come to an end, we are excited for the future scientific discoveries it has opened by setting the foundation for the next generation planetary defense telescope.”
During its nearly fifteen years of operations, the space telescope exceeded its scientific objectives (not once but twice) by remaining in operation far longer than expected. When it first launched as the WISE mission in 2009, the mission was intended to scan the infrared sky for seven months. By July 2010, the mission had accomplished this objective with far greater sensitivity than previous IR surveys and depleted its supply of solid hydrogen coolant a few months later. The mission was then extended until February 2011 under the name NEOWISE to complete its survey of the Main Asteroid Belt, at which point it was put into hibernation.
However, analysis of the WISE/NEOWISE data revealed that it could still operate without coolant and make precise observations of less faint objects like comets and asteroids that are heated by the Sun as they fly closer to our planet – in short, Near-Earth Objects (NEOs). By 2013, NASA recommissioned the space telescope under the Near-Earth Object Observations Program, which morphed into NASA’s Planetary Defense Coordination Office (PDCO) in 2016. Data processing for WISE and NEOWISE takes place at the Infrared Processing and Analysis Center at the California Institute of Technology (Caltech).
This illustration shows NASA’s NEO Surveyor against an infrared observation of a starfield made by the agency’s WISE mission. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/University of ArizonaSaid Amy Mainzer, the principal investigator of NEOWISE and NEO Surveyor at UCLA:
“After developing new techniques to find and characterize near-Earth objects hidden in vast quantities of its infrared survey data, NEOWISE has become key in helping us develop and operate NASA’s next-generation infrared space telescope. It is a precursor mission. NEO Surveyor will seek out the most difficult-to-find asteroids and comets that could cause significant damage to Earth if we don’t find them first.”
The NEOWISE mission conducted about 1.45 million infrared measurements of more than 44,000 solar system objects, which were used to create all-sky infrared maps. This included 215 of the more than 3,000 NEOs detected to date and 25 new comets. This included the long-period comet C/2020 F3 NEOWISE that appeared in the night sky during the summer of 2020 and was the brightest comet seen in the northern hemisphere since Comet Hale–Bopp streaked across the sky in 1997.
“The NEOWISE mission has been instrumental in our quest to map the skies and understand the near-Earth environment. Its huge number of discoveries have expanded our knowledge of asteroids and comets, while also boosting our nation’s planetary defense,” said Laurie Leshin, the director of NASA JPL. “As we bid farewell to NEOWISE, we also celebrate the team behind it for their impressive achievements.”
In addition to leaving behind volumes of scientific data, WISE and NEOWISE helped pave the way for NASA’s next-generation infrared space telescope. This mission, the Near-Earth Object Surveyor (NEO Surveyor), will be the first purpose-built mission dedicated to monitoring potentially hazardous NEOs. Once operational, it will seek out some of the faintest NEOs, such as asteroids and comets with low albedos (meaning they don’t reflect much visible light) or those that approach Earth from the direction of the Sun. This telescope is currently under construction and will launch no earlier than 2027.
Further Reading: NASA
The post NASA’s Says Goodbye to its Asteroid-Hunting NEOWISE Mission appeared first on Universe Today.
Mars was once wet, but now its surface is desiccated. Its meagre atmosphere contains only a tiny trace amount of water vapour. But new research says the planet contains ample liquid water. Unfortunately, it’s kilometres under the surface, well out of reach.
The question of what happened to Mars’ water is an enduring one. There’s ample evidence showing that water flowed across the planet’s surface, carving out river channels, creating sediment deltas, and filling lakes. It may even have had ocenas. The planet was likely warm and wet until around 3.8 billion years ago, during the transition from the Noachian Period to the Hesperian Period. Over time it lost both its thick atmosphere and its water.
The most widely accepted explanation for the water’s disappearance is that the planet’s magnetic shield weakened and that the solar wind blew most of the water away into space.
New research published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) presents a new wrinkle in the Mars water mystery. Its title is “Liquid water in the Martian mid-crust,” and the first author is Vashan Wright, an assistant professor at UC San Diego’s Scripps Institution of Oceanography.
“Understanding the Martian water cycle is critical for understanding the evolution of the climate, surface and interior,” Wright said in a press release. “A useful starting point is to identify where water is and how much is there.”
Wright and his colleagues worked with data from NASA’s InSight lander, which was sent to Mars to study the planet’s deep interior. InSight aimed to understand not only Mars but also the processes that shape all rocky planets. The mission ended in December 2022 when the lander became unresponsive, but scientists are still working with its data.
During its mission, InSight gathered seismic data with SEIS, the Seismic Experiment for Interior Structure. SEIS was sensitive to Marsquakes and meteorite impacts, and the seismic data is helping scientists understand Mars’ interior, including its core, mantle, and crust.
This image shows InSight’s SEIS, the Seismic Experiment for Interior Structure. It’s housed under a protective dome that shields it from wind and dust. Credit: NASA/JPL“Large volumes of liquid water transiently existed on the surface of Mars more than 3 billion years ago,” the authors write in their published research. “Much of this water is hypothesized to have been sequestered in the subsurface or lost to space.”
Seismic waves sensed by SEIS can help determine if some of Mars’ water is in the planet’s subsurface. When seismic waves travel through a planet, they reveal information about the inner structure and composition. There are different types of waves, and some can’t travel through liquids. That’s how scientists learned that Earth has a liquid core.
Wave velocities and directions also reveal a lot. Velocity and direction change when the waves reach boundaries like the one between a planet’s crust and its mantle. Waves also provide information about the density and elasticity of materials they pass through. Changes in wave speed also reveal information about temperature differences.
But conclusions don’t jump out of data and announce themselves. Researchers have to work their way through the data and try to interpret it. The Mars science community is doing just that, and this research is the latest part of the effort.
Previous researchers have tried to constrain the conditions under the InSight Lander in Elysium Planitia. Scientists use the term upper crust to describe the depth down to about 8km and the term lower crust to describe the depth between 8 km and about 20 km. Some research from orbiters showed that the upper crust is like a cryosphere that contains abundant frozen water. Orbital images of recent meteorite impacts appear to show exposed ice.
But this new research goes against that. The authors write that seismic waves “in the upper 8 km beneath InSight is lower than expected for an ice-saturated cryosphere.”
Previous research also showed that the lower crust contains either highly porous mafic rock or less porous felsic rock. However, it was difficult to determine how much water was contained in the pores.
That’s where this research comes in.
“We assess whether Vs, Vp, and bulk density ?b data are consistent with liquid water-saturated pores in the mid-crust (11.5 ± 3.1 to 20 ± 5km) within 50 km of the InSight lander,” the authors write. Vs means the velocity of secondary seismic waves, Vp means the velocity of primary seismic waves, and pb means bulk density. The bulk density means the mass of a volume unit of rock including any liquid trapped in its pores.
According to the authors, the mid-crust is one of our identifiable layers under the InSight lander. It may even be global, but there is not enough data to conclude that yet.
However, the researchers did reach another conclusion: “A mid-crust composed of igneous rock with thin fractures filled with liquid water can best explain the geophysical data.”
If the InSight Lander location is representative of the rest of Mars, the approximately 11.5 km to 20 km deep mid-crust could hold an enormous amount of water. There could be enough to cover the entire planet in a layer of water 1 to 2 km deep. Of course, this is just a thought exercise since Mars’ wouldn’t be able to hold onto the surface water.
If the planet does hold such a vast amount of water, it won’t be of much use to human visitors trying to establish a presence there. Even on Earth, drilling only 1 km into the surface is difficult. It’s challenging to conceive of a way to drill 11 km deep on Mars.
But where there’s water, there could be life.
“Establishing that there is a big reservoir of liquid water provides some window into what the climate was like or could be like,” said co-author Michael Manga, a UC Berkeley professor of earth and planetary science. “And water is necessary for life as we know it. I don’t see why [the underground reservoir] is not a habitable environment.”
It may very well be habitable, but that doesn’t mean it’s inhabited. It is at least a possibility, though.
We’ve found life at a depth of 5 km within Earth’s crust. Could the same thing be possible on Mars?
Just like the water, an answer to that question is well out of reach. For now.
The post Mars Has Lots of Water, But It’s Out of Reach appeared first on Universe Today.